By Charles Bricker
I’ve not only seen this Venus Williams comeback before, I think I’ve previously seen that red frock she was wearing on Monday at the Sony Ericsson Open.
Didn’t Miss Kitty wear that outfit in an episode of “Gunsmoke?”
That was a real dance hall costume Williams played in for her round-of-16 win over Daniela Hantuchova, but she wasn’t boogeying very well for much of this match and, though she won and still looks like a bonafide top-10 player, the reality for Venus is that her championship days are probably over.
Is she still a world class player? Yes. Is she still a threat on one of those “any given Sundays?” Or Mondays. Or Tuesdays. Yes. But she hasn’t won any of the top eight Sony Ericsson WTA Tour tournaments she enters since the WTA Championships of 2008, and she doesn’t look as if she has the stuff to win Key Biscayne this week, either.
This 1-6, 7-5, 6-4 victory, extending her record against Hantuchova to 10-0, could easily have been another embarrassing loss.
Her forehand accounted for 14 unforced errors in the first set alone and her second serve continues to give opponents another place to attack. She’s still gritty, of course, and used all of her personal confidence, plus Hantuchova’s case of third-set yips, to revive herself down the stretch to earn a quarterfinal meeting with No. 6 Agnieszka Radwanska.
She’s going to win her share of matches, and I don’t dispute that she could reach the semis here. But it’s a very real question if she’ll ever win another big event ($4.5 million in prize money or more), for a number of reasons.
She’s 29. That doesn’t mean she needs a wheelchair to get on court, but it does mean that there is going to be more of a fatigue factor as she gets deeper into the draws of these major events. The forehand is in and out and there are players a lot better than Hantuchova who will do a better job of exploiting it. There is now a major dropoff in quality and pace between her first and second serves. That second serve at times looks as big as a pumpkin. Finally, the competition at the top is much tougher — not just from her sister, but from Justine Henin and Kim Clijsters, and there are a couple of ingenues out there who also could be a major factor by the end of the year — most notably Yanina Wickmayer and Caroline Wozniacki.
Let’s look at what Williams has done in the last 16 months in the eight biggest tournaments she enters:
* Out in the second round of the 2009 Australian Open to No. 46 Carla Suarez Navarro.
* Out in the semis of the 2009 Key Biscayne to No. 1 Serena Williams.
* Out in the semis of the 2009 Madrid to No. 1 Dinara Safina.
* Out in the third round of the 2009 French Open to No. 31 Agnes Szavay.
* Out in the final of the 2009 Wimbledon to No. 2 Serena.
* Out in the round of 16 of the 2009 U.S. Open to Kim Clijsters, who had no ranking because she had just come back on tour.
* Out in the second round of the 2009 Beijing to No. 39 Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova.
* Out in the final of the WTA Tour Championships to No. 2 Serena.
* Out in the quarters of the 2010 Australian Open to No. 17 Li Na.
We haven’t even gone into injuries here, but with the secretive Williams family, one never knows how serious things are until one of the sisters pulls out of a tournament. Venus is wearing a pretty heavy wrapping on her right leg, from just above the knee to mid-thigh, during the Sony Ericsson Open. It didn’t look to inhibit her running in the least, as she pulled off a couple of running backhands that got people to their feet.
But she’s missed significant time in the past with physical problems and, at 29, it’s only realistic to think she’s going to miss more.
Notwithstanding her tennis garb for this tournament, she’s usually pretty elegant — on and off the court. If she’s going to win something big, it probably will be Wimbledon, where the points are quicker and her serving is more of a plus on the grass. But it’s not the mid-2000s any longer and while she’s still a very competitive force in any match, the championship days are probably over.
Charles Bricker can be reached at nflwriterr@aol.com