The Billie Jean King USTA National Tennis Center got a beat down from Hurricane Irene and 33 Americans entered in the U.S. Open qualifying tournaments got a beat down from the international competition.
The unpleasant results: Not one of 15 U.S. women entered in the 128-draw qualifying got through to the main draw. Worse, not one U.S. women got to the third and final round of qualifying.
On the men’s side, where 18 mostly young and aspiring U.S. players were entered, just one reached the big show and, at 30 years of age, No. 208-ranked qualifier Michael Yani is not quite the future of American tennis.
It shouldn’t be considered a complete loss or waste of resources. Coaches with the prodigiously-funded USTA player development program will tell you that, even in losses, it was an important experience for promising talent Chichi Scholl (19 years old), Jessica Pegula (17) and Taylor Townsend (15), who each won a round, and for Robin Anderson (18), Anne-Liz Jeukeng-Nkamgouo (15) and Nicole Gibbs (18), who all went out quickly.
And that would be a strong point to some degree because qualifying results at a Grand Slam aren’t going to tell you much about a 15-year-old player. At the same time, if you look at the U.S. performance in qualifying on balance, the results these last three days are not good — especially playing on home turf.
Only four women won qualifying matches — Scholl, Pegula, Townsend and Ashley Weinhold. Only Townsend extended an opponent to a third-set in second-round losses.
There were some bad first-round losses. Seeded No. 27, Alexa Glatch lost 6-3, 6-0, Krista Hardebeck was beaten 6-0, 6-2 by Scholl and Gail Brodsky went down love and love to No. 3 seed Stephanie Dubois of Canada.
A year ago, Irina Falconi, 21, was the only American to qualify for the Open. Born in Ecuador, she finished last year at No. 210 and comes into the Open this week at No. 78. She’s making progress, but, at this point, she’s a prospect. Nothing more.
One other woman who needs a mention in No. 66 Christina McHale, 19, who had a win over No. 1 Caroline Wozniacki last week in Cincinnati before going out in the third round to Nadia Petrova. She’s going to elevate to low- to mid-50s in the rankings on Monday. She’s having a strong development year and we’ll see if you can back up her Wozniacki with results at the Open.
United States men had somewhat better fortunes in the qualifying with Denis Kudla, Bradley Klahn and Rejeev Ram joining Yani in the final round. Unfortunately for Ram and Yani, they played each other in the third round, guaranteeing that not only would one Yank make the main draw but at least one would not.
Meanwhile, Klahn, who had beaten No. 14 seed Matthew Ebden in the second round, lost 6-3 in the third to go out, and Kudla, a winner over No. 24 Evgeny Donskoy in the second, lost 6-4, 6-2.
Other first-round winners were Greg Ouelette, Rhyne Williams, Mitchell Frank and Blake Strode. Certainly USTA officials would be quick to support the federation’s development program by pointing out that eight American men won opening-round qualifying matches.
That’s fine, but it’s not enough, of course, unless you’re still measuring the program in baby steps.
That’s not to say there aren’t very talented young U.S. players. Ryan Harrison, 19, has moved to No. 67 in the world with steady if not spectacular progress, and there is 16-year-old Madison Keys, who is ranked mid-400s and who is probably not going to give us a full measure of her talent for at least a couple years.
You look at the rest of the young American talent out there and it’s very hard to say there’s anyone destined for tennis’ elite.
With qualifying over, there will be 13 U.S. men in the main draw, led by Mardy Fish, Andy Roddick and John Isner, and 15 women, with Serena Williams a contender for the title. Six U.S. men and six women are in the main draw with wild cards.